Strength training after 40: balancing progress, fatigue and joint comfort
Strength training after 40 can serve several aims: building muscle, increasing strength, and retaining abilities such as climbing stairs or getting up from the floor. A harder session may advance one aim while making the next session more difficult. The useful question is which kind of progress the extra effort produces, and whether you can sustain it.
Measure strength and everyday ability separately
Peter Attia and Michael Rae’s strength playbook uses everyday abilities to frame training goals. That is a useful perspective, but a stronger lift or a thicker muscle does not, by itself, establish that someone will retain a particular ability years later.
A trial in 100 frail nursing-home residents found improvements in strength, walking speed and stair-climbing power after ten weeks of resistance training. It shows that people in this population could improve these measured outcomes; it cannot predict an individual’s long-term independence. Fiatarone et al., *New England Journal of Medicine*, 1994.
If everyday function is part of your goal, observe it separately from changes in gym performance. The distinction keeps a gain in muscle size from being mistaken for a demonstrated gain in function.
A challenging load does not require an all-out set
In the Danish LISA trial, 451 adults of retirement age were assigned to a year of heavy resistance training, moderate training or a control group. Four years after the trial began, the heavy-training group had maintained its baseline isometric leg strength on average, while the other groups had declined. The groups also differed in setting and supervision, so the comparison does not isolate load alone. Leg power, the trial’s primary outcome, did not show the same differential preservation. Bloch-Ibenfeldt et al., *BMJ Open Sport & Exercise Medicine*, 2024.
This supports taking strength development seriously in later life. It does not establish that every set must end in failure, the point at which another repetition is not possible. Load and proximity to failure are different programming choices.
In a separate eight-week study, 18 resistance-trained participants trained one leg to failure and stopped the other leg with an estimated one or two repetitions remaining, depending on the exercise. Average quadriceps growth was similar between conditions. Training to failure caused greater losses in lifting speed and repetitions across sets, measures of fatigue during training. Refalo et al., *Journal of Sports Sciences*, 2024.
That small study suggests an option for managing fatigue while pursuing muscle growth. It did not test long-term function, joint pain or injury prevention in adults over 40. The number of repetitions someone believes they have left is also an estimate, not a precise measurement.
More work can help some outcomes, but its ideal dose is unknown
Managing fatigue does not mean assuming that fewer sets are always better. In a study of older women who trained twice weekly, both one-set and three-set groups improved. After 20 weeks, the three-set group had greater gains in knee-extension strength and lower-body muscle thickness, though the advantage was not consistent across every outcome. Radaelli et al., *AGE*, 2014.
Additional sets can therefore matter for a particular goal and population. This comparison does not identify an ideal weekly workload for everyone. Before adding work, it helps to identify the outcome you want to change and whether your current sessions remain manageable. A tiring session alone is neither evidence of progress nor a reason to add more sets.
Joint comfort is a constraint; pain relief is a separate claim
In Attia’s conversation with Jeff Cavaliere, adapting uncomfortable movements is presented as a way to keep training. Exercise choice can be adjusted to what a person tolerates, but expert coaching advice does not establish that a particular substitution prevents injury.
The distinction between strength training and pain relief also matters. In the START trial, 377 adults aged 50 or older with knee osteoarthritis were assigned to high-intensity strength training, low-intensity training or an attention-control group. At 18 months, high-intensity training had not significantly reduced knee pain or knee compressive forces during walking compared with the alternatives. That result does not show that strength training harms knees; it limits a claim that training harder will relieve knee pain. Messier et al., *JAMA*, 2021.
Personal observation can help identify which movements and workloads feel tolerable. It cannot establish that a choice protects a joint from injury. Persistent or worsening pain calls for assessment by a qualified clinician.
The studies support pursuing measurable strength gains and keeping muscle size, tested strength and everyday function distinct. They suggest that additional sets can improve some outcomes and that all-out sets are not established as necessary for muscle growth in the conditions studied. They leave open the ideal workload, stopping point and exercise choice for an individual adult over 40. Those decisions should respond to a specific goal and to how well the training remains tolerable over repeated sessions, without treating a strength gain as proof of future function or pain relief.
Sources
- Peter Attia and Michael Rae. A longevity playbook for building strength and muscle mass. Editorial context.
- Peter Attia with Jeff Cavaliere. Resistance training as we age, episode 414. Expert commentary.
- Fiatarone et al., 1994. Resistance training and physical frailty.
- Bloch-Ibenfeldt et al., 2024. Four-year follow-up of resistance training.
- Refalo et al., 2024. Muscle growth with failure versus repetitions in reserve.
- Radaelli et al., 2014. Low-volume and high-volume training in older women.
- Messier et al., 2021. The START knee osteoarthritis trial.
Text written with the help of AI.